- 1996 Playoff Qualifiers
- 1997 D3Pro Mid Atlantic Division Champions
- 1997 Franchise of the Year
- 2008 PDL Mid-Atlantic Division Champions
- 2008 PDL Eastern Conference Regular Season Champions
- 2008 PDL National Semifinalists
- 2009 PDL Mid-Atlantic Division Champions
- 2009 PDL Regular Season National Champions
- 2009 PDL Player of the Year – Aaron Wheeler
- 2009 USL Marketing Award
- 2010 PDL Mid-Atlantic Division Champions
- 2010 PDL Eastern Conference Champions
- 2010 PDL National Semifinalists
- 2010 PDL Defender of the Year Finalist – Matt Hedges
- 2010 PDL Coach of the Year Finalist – Brendan Burke
- 2011 PDL Rookie of the Year Finalist – Brian Holt
